Set in the early nineteenth-century in Edinburgh, this powerful historical drama follows two women, Marianne Woods (Clare Dunne) and Jane Pirie (Fiona Nicholson, co-screenwriter). In an attempt to lead a quaint life, outside of the strict societal norms, they run a small boarding school for girls – but their lives face a significant shift after a wealthy woman enrols her three granddaughters, one of which is her ‘illegitimate’ grandchild from India, Jane Cumming (Mia Tharia).
Jane is constantly treated as an outsider by her cousins and fellow classmates due to her skin colour being different to that of the other girls. She faces constant exclusion, and the desperate need to belong, which Mia Tharia conveys brilliantly. When the two women are tasked with looking after Jane over the summer, their relationship blossoms into a beautiful family-like dynamic. Jane even teaches Miss Woods and Miss Pirie how to swim. However, this bliss soon fades when Jane requests to stay on at the school permanently. The women reject this request, claiming that children should not stay at school forever. Feeling rejected by her newly found family, Jane demands to be returned to her grandmother’s care. There, she accuses the two women of lesbianism – a shocking scandal which is followed by a decade long legal battle.
Directed and co-written by Sophie Heldman, this beautifully crafted film is based on the real case which took place in 1810. The film was shot with a modest budget, drawing viewers in with its compelling story, portrayed excellently through the emotionally provoking performances by Fiona Shaw, who presented Miss Pirie as a stern, work driven individual throughout the film. This made her breakdown even more gut-wrenching as it is the first time the audience witnessed her lose control. It was the impending shift that we all felt was coming. In contrast, Clare Dunne played the softer Miss Woods, who is seen to carry her heart on her sleeve and manages to obtain this image of class even after the allegations had been made against them both. The film primarily focuses on sensitive themes such as race, and sexuality. It emphasises the struggles that so many have had to suffer through for being deemed as ‘different’.
‘The Education of Jane Cumming’ uses a variety of elegantly framed shots to convey a seemingly steady atmosphere. The simplistic cinematography of the film provides the audience with a sense of peace and tranquillity which is highlighted using a relatively neutral colour palette. However, the use of bleak-coloured back drops and grey skies foreshadow that this peace will not last, and there is a dark storm which is yet to come. Therefore, making the shift in atmosphere feel even more apparent once Jane has reported the two teachers, resulting in their inevitable downfall.
Whilst I considered the film to be an interesting drama, it was most definitely a slow burner. The story seemed to be told mainly through a series of elongated stares between characters as opposed to action. If you are someone who enjoys an action-packed / visually compelling film, then this would likely not be a good choice for your typical movie night.
The film presents a classic tale of love, betrayal and mistreatment in an unforgiving world. It is amazing that festivals such as Brighton’s Cinecity provide opportunities to give films like these the recognition they truly deserve.